Maybe you've noticed screwcaps on more of the higher priced wines lately. The trend is continuing to grow and so is the debate of whether a screwcap or cork is better for wine. The industry has basically "agreed to disagree" as to whether wine bottled with a screwcap or a cork tastes better, ages better and has less of a tendency to spoil.

As more wineries consider using screwcaps instead of the traditional cork, one has to wonder how the public at large will accept the change in tradition. When the occasional wine drinker sees a $20 bottle of wine with a screwcap, will he move to the next bottle on the shelf because he conjuring thoughts in his mind of his college years and Boones Farm Apple Wine?

Corks hold tradition and romance for a bottle of wine. It's hard to imagine dining at a fine eating establishment and ordering a bottle of wine without expecting the waiter pull out his corkscrew. Watching him carefully cut the foil, masterfully twist the screw into the cork, and giving it a pull with a final, ever so slight, pop, is part of what we pay for when we order a bottle of wine. It's shear romance; it's a moment we hold in our memory of a nice dining experience.

Why would a winery want to change an age-old tradition that holds so much charm? Well, apparently the occurrence of wines being spoiled because of the cork is a fairly large problem. One report from the International Wine Challenge, the world's largest wine competition, states that nearly one in 20 bottles, or 4.9% of the 11,033 bottles opened at that competition had spoiled or the flavor had been flattened because of the cork.

How is the cork responsible for the ruin of so much wine? Cork is a tree bark and when wine corks are manufactured, chlorine bleach is used for cleaning and brightening the color. When the bleach comes in contact with the natural molds that are present in the cork, a reaction occurs and a chemical called trichloroanisole (TCA) is produced. If this chemical comes in contact with the wine, it will cause it to taste like damp cardboard. When this happens the wine is then referred to as being "corked", and it is undrinkable.

Screwcaps have proven themselves to be a better alternative to cork. First developed in Australia, the brand name for screwcaps used for wine is Stelvin, so you will often hear them referred to as such. These caps are not the same as those used for food and drink; these caps are specially designed to protect fine wines from tainting for a period of time and to allow for aging. Basically the part of the cap that actually contacts the wine is made from a thin coating of Teflon film over pure tin, this gives the cap the capability to stay stable and flavor-neutral for a very long time.

There are some screwcap critics that say the Stelvin caps don't allow for proper "breathing" so the wine can age, however, this is a myth. If a cork is perfect and works the way it is supposed to work, it will not allow air into the bottle. Actually, oxygen is potentially harmful to the wine and very unnecessary for the aging process. To quote a leading Bordeaux authority Professor Pascal Rib?reau-Gayon in the "Handbook of Enology",

"reactions that take place in bottled wine do not require oxygen".

And one more authority, Professor Emile Peynaud of Bordeaux says,

"it is the opposite of oxidation, a process of reduction, or asphyxia by which wine develops in the bottle"

So, as we watch a trend develop of vintners moving toward using screwcaps we, the wine-drinking public, are just going to have to come to terms with the fact that screwcaps have proven themselves. Because of the Stelvin, we consumers will be able to enjoy better preserved and better tasting wine in the years to come. Actually, instead of thinking about moving to the next bottle on the shelf because of the screwcap, we should be seeking out the wine that delights your palate regardless of whether it uses a screwcap or not.

About the Author

David-The Wine Gift Guy loves to drink wine. Read his experiences, reviews, and recommendations at The Wine Gift Guy. Comments at the site are encouraged, stop by & help David build a great big, snob-free, wine-loving community.

Another short Wine Cellars review

Screwcaps For Wine - Is It Bye-Bye To The Romance?


Maybe you've noticed screwcaps on more of the higher priced wines lately. The trend is continuing to grow and so is the debate of whether a screwcap o...


Click Here to Read More About Wine ...

Recommended Wine Cellars Items

The FTD Splendid Day Bouquet - Standard


A beautiful display of scintillating pink and fuchsia blooms in a glass vase. Flowers include a mini gerbera daisy, spray roses, lisianthus and more. C5-3019S


Price: 62.99 USD



Current Wine Cellars News

Wine Spectator è nudo

Fri, 22 Aug 08 01:37:32 -0700
La burla di un economista ai danni di Wine Spectator. Come condurre un esperimento per farsi assegnare un premio per un ristorante che non esiste. Ma quali saranno gli effetti di questo?

Fake Restaurant Wins Award of Excellence

Wed, 20 Aug 08 17:37:05 -0700
He typed up a menu (”a fun amalgamation of somewhat bumbling nouvelle-Italian recipes”) and then put together a wine list, and submitted both to Wine Spectator–along with the $250 fee. The list was approved and given an Award of Excellence.

Fake Wine List Spells Trouble for Wine Spectator

Wed, 20 Aug 08 14:52:11 -0700
Writer Robin Goldstein wins Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator Magazine for fake restaurant. Even more outrageous, the terrible (fake) wine list!

Bogus restaurant wins Wine Spectator Award of Excellence

Wed, 20 Aug 08 05:15:03 -0700
A non-existent restaurant applies for and receives an Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator magazine.

Wine Spectator gives Excellence Award to fake restaurant

Wed, 20 Aug 08 02:22:45 -0700
Wine Spectator gives an award of excellence to a non-existent restaurant.

Wine Spectator Restaurant Awards Exposed as a Total Farce

Tue, 19 Aug 08 20:20:44 -0700
Held up as one of the gold standards of quality wine judgement, a researcher has performed a sting operation on the Spectator Wine Awards by getting an award for a fake restaurant with a wine list of the lowest scoring wines from the same magazine.

Economists Question Real Value of Wine

Tue, 19 Aug 08 16:23:12 -0700
Author describes sting of Wine Spectator awards to indicate perceptions may rest on false inferences


Aging Wine
Wine Varieties

Labels: Wine Commercials | Wine Companies

&type=page">